All this hype surrounding the Keto Diet, Paleo, Weight Watchers… but which one is right for me???
So you’re looking for a new diet plan…or maybe it’s not a diet plan, but instead a general list of foods that you will consume on a regular basis and make it a lifestyle. So what do you do? Bust out ol’ Google and search for the latest and “greatest” diet plans.
Then you see a smörgåsbord of different diets with scientists claiming that theirs is the best one. You’ll see the paleo diet, keto diet, vegan, Atkins, weight watchers, the carnivore diet, blah, blah, blah. But how do you know which diet is right for you? They try to convince you with latest, cutting-edge research backed by Yale and Harvard researchers, that THIS is the best diet for you. Or they put up a picture of Oprah holding a plate of greens to convince you her diet is the one for you. So as she cashes in on a multi-billion dollar market, you should know what’s right for you!
But it seems every new diet enters an inevitable cycle. A new ‘fad’ diet is introduced, then research is conducted to validate it’s efficacy, and finally some 6 months later there is research done disproving the effectiveness of this diet. This happens not only with diets but also with individual foods, vitamins and minerals.
Remember the whole coconut oil saga? Studies came out showing how great and healthy coconut oil is and that you should be substituting all of your oils with it. Probably promoted by the coconut oil lobby (if you’re a fan of conspiracy theories). But several months later, Harvard released a paper talking about how bad coconut oil is for you. That it’s about 90% unsaturated fat, which is higher content than that found in butter, beef fad and even lard.
So which diet should you chose? Who do I trust? Truth is, you should only trust yourself and your own body. These diets are based on general data that assumes a particular diet would be good for the general population. But these doctors and researchers don’t know YOUR medical history and what if you don’t fall in to the “general” population pool? They really have no idea. Each individual has a unique reaction to particular foods. Knowing how your body and brain reacts to these foods is the key to optimizing your diet. “this is impossible,” you might be thinking. But it’s not. You can do this with heart rate variability(HRV)
Innovative Health Technology
It’s a phenomenon that’s been sweeping the nation! As Fitbit sticks to its guns by tracking steps, several innovative and disruptive tech companies have moved on to a new biomarker that gives people a window into their internal health. One that can be a tremendous tool as a means to improve overall health.
Heart Rate Variability (HRV) is a true indicator of overall health. HRV reflects the capacity of the body to deal with on-going demands (Young and Benton, 2015). What is does is measure the time difference between each successive heartbeat; the higher the difference (variability) generally the healthier the individual. (for more details on HRV, read our first blog post)
Heart Rate Variability
Essentially, HRV gives us a snapshot of your overall heart health at any given time throughout the day. And this can change based on stress on that particular day, as well as other factors; a main one being food. It’s an amazing tool, and perhaps the only one that can truly optimize your diet and help find a nutrition plan that’s perfect for you. Though sites like 23andMe claim they can help tailor diets specific to the individual by studying ones genetic dispositions. However, these studies are still in their infancy and don’t have enough clinical evidence whereas HRV does.
How Can Heart Rate Variability Improve Diet?
It’s quite simple, you want high heart rate variability since it indicates a healthy functioning body. Typically HRV is measured for 2 – 5 minutes and then give you a score at the end. Different wearables and apps will display results in their own way. Whoop, for example gives you a score based on percentage. Apps like EliteHRV show essentially the same thing (a score out of 100). Then there’s the AIO Smart Sleeve, which shows you a score out of 5 stars.
So the way food affects our bodies is in the way our bodies and brains react. Every time you eat, your brain (specifically the autonomic nervous system) sends a signal to the rest of your body to digest the food you ate. And every one is different in the way they react to food, specifically how much stress they are putting their body under with certain foods.
Unhealthy foods, or maybe foods that don’t agree with you, will elicit a stress response; a response that can only be captured by using heart rate variability. But we can’t generalize certain foods as being universally unhealthy or universally healthy because everyone has different reactions. So if you eat unhealthy food, as deemed by your body, your HRV will decrease and vice versa.
Carbs are terrible, right? We’ve heard for years now, “eat less white rice, switch to whole wheat bread, no more pasta!” Well then why does Japan have the second highest life expectancy (of 84.74 years) despite the fact that the Japanese diet is very high in carbs? Why do other countries who have predominantly high carb diets, like Italy, constantly surpass countries like Canada and the United States (where these faddiets are prominent) in this statistical category?
To be fair, life expectancy is not the end all, be all stat, but it does carry some significance. Typically these two countries have a quite healthy population despite scientific research that claims carbs are cancerous, and can lead to diabetes. So why are carbs ok there and not other places?
Get The Full Picture
Much of this research and clinical data does not look at other factors such as lifestyle. Does a person smoke, drink, exercise, carry other stress from work, not get enough sleep, and so on. There are so many factors that it’s impossible to say that a cookie-cutter diet will work for a person. It’s just not realistic.
Take Control of Your Health
Heart rate variability gives you all the power. Be your own boss! Try a diet or try certain foods and see how your body reacts. You can plug in different diets or types of food into your routine and see if they work for you. What you do is measure your HRV before you eat and then 30 – 60 minutes after you eat and see by how much your HRV decreased. For example, if you eat a salad with minimal dressing, your HRV might only slightly decrease as compared to if you ate a Big Mac Meal from McDonalds. Or maybe not! Only one way to find out and that’s by testing it yourself.
Big Mac HRV case study
There was a small case study done with the effect that one Big Mac meal has on HRV; Nothing extremely significant, but still an anecdotal study. The device used was the AIO Smart Sleeve+ the AIO Sleeve App. There were 10 subjects between the ages of 25 to 60. Two groups were used, between 25 – 40 and 41 – 60. Here were the results:
|Age Group||HRV Before Meal (avg.)||HRV After Meal (avg.)|
|25 – 40||3.8||3.1|
|41 – 60||3.2||2.2|
The results show that the 25 – 40 age group saw an HRV reduction of 0.7 (out of 5 stars) and the 41 – 60 age group saw a full 1-point reduction. It’s necessary to point out that many studies show that HRV generally decreases with age, and many other variables were not considered in this case study (further research will be published soon).
So not only does this show that this generally unhealthy meal reduces HRV, the reduction level is different among age groups, and each individual had a unique response (not a single one had equal results).
Much has been made about intermittent fasting and caloric restriction in the past several years as well. Restricting your eating window to just 8 hours of the day. Again, studies show significant health improvements but is this technique right for you? There’s a way you can test this on yourself by using a method that is widely known in the HRV community and it’s called morning readiness.
Jumpstart Your Day
Morning readiness is measuring your heart rate variability in the morning, which gives you a sense of overall health and resilience to start the day. High HRV means your starting your day off on the right foot! So Let’s say you’re currently on a normal diet and your last meal is at 8pm. Measure HRV before your meal, once after and then once in the morning before breakfast. Take note, and then do the same when you try fasting.
The general fasting window is 16 hours. So let’s say you’re last meal is at 6pm and first meal the next day is at 10am. Measure before you eat, after, and in the morning. See how it varies. If you recover quicker and your HRV is higher with fasting, then maybe it’s something you’ll want to keep up!
It goes without saying that alcohol doesn’t exactly coincide with healthy lifestyles but we’ve all seen studies and articles saying 1 glass of wine a day is actually good for heart health. Even the Mayo Clinic approves. But in recent years this theory has been completely debunked. Even though alcohol isn’t great for you, we all have the urge to have a beverage in evening with dinner after a long day of work.
You can use HRV to see what amount of alcohol is okay for your body, as well as which types of alcohol have worse effects. Try this: See how your HRV responds after drinking each type of alcohol. Try wine one night, whiskey the next and so on. Disclaimer: We don’t encourage binge drinking, but you got to do what you got to do! We will be conducting this experiment in depth and posting the results soon. We’ll be doing this strictly for scientific purposes…(wink, wink)
Inflammation that you would get from certain foods is also heavily connected to heart rate variability. If some food causes you inflammation, it will show with a reduced HRV. It’s due to something called a C-reactive protein (CRP). This is something that is produced by the liver in response to inflammation. And HRV is associated with the production of these proteins, and that why it can tell you if some foods cause inflammation.
Which Diet Is Right For You?
So now you’re saying, “I read this whole thing and I still don’t know what diet I should follow, WHAT DO I DO???” Well, we can’t tell you, and neither can some article or a doctor from Harvard who’s never examined you. Frankly, they don’t know you from a can of paint. What we can do is equip you with the knowledge, and the most cutting edge technology so you can easily do it yourself, from the comfort of your own home, gym of office.
Another noteworthy item: When choosing a diet plan, people get hooked by pictures of models who toned, tanned, and all that. But having a 6-pack doesn’t always correlate with a healthy body and heart. Just look at the Mr. Olympia contestants (bodybuilders).C They have muscles on top of more muscles with a 4% body fat. But this doesn’t mean that internally, they are healthy. All of the “supplements” they take are doing significant damage and their heart is working like crazy, and it’s why there are many cases of heart problems as they age.
Optimize Your Life
This doesn’t mean you can’t get the desired look from these diets, of course you can. But with HRV you can optimize you diet and have your body running like Ferrari and not a 1980’s broken down Chevy.
In our future blogs, we will be posting results of our case studies with regards to how fast food affects HRV and also how different types of alcohol affect HRV. So stay tuned!!